The Lubbock Lights, 1951: what the professors measured and what a student photographed
On the evening of August 25, 1951, four college professors in Lubbock, Texas, watched an arc of lights pass overhead in a few seconds. Over the following weeks they saw it about a dozen more times, and a freshman photographed the lights. The Air Force investigation could not identify them.
- When: August 25, 1951
- Where: United States
- Witnesses: four Texas Tech professors, college student Carl Hart Jr. and hundreds of Lubbock residents
- Official position: Project Grudge / Project Blue Book: unknown. Ruppelt's personal view changed: in 1954 he thought they were birds, in 1956 an undisclosed natural phenomenon.
An August evening in Lubbock
On the evening of August 25, 1951, four professors were sitting in the backyard of geologist W. I. Robinson in Lubbock, Texas. All four taught at Texas Technological College (now Texas Tech University). Along with Robinson were chemical engineer A. G. Oberg, petroleum engineering department head W. L. Ducker and physicist E. F. George. According to the Air Force report, at about 9:10 p.m. a group of lights passed overhead from north to south.
Each group held 20 to 30 lights, and the first two formations made an almost perfect semicircle. The lights were about as bright as a bright star but looked larger. There was no sound. The witnesses disagreed about the color: the Air Force report lists blue-white, while the professors' notes say yellowish to white. Air Force investigator Edward Ruppelt later described them as bluish green.
Lubbock was not the only place with a report that night. According to Ruppelt, about twenty minutes earlier, on the outskirts of Albuquerque, New Mexico, a couple saw a silent "flying wing" with bluish lights along its trailing edge. The husband worked for the Sandia Corporation. Albuquerque is about 400 km from Lubbock.
Trying to measure them
Over the following weeks the professors saw the lights about a dozen more times and tried to measure them. According to the Air Force report, the lights appeared about 45 degrees above the northern horizon and disappeared about 45 degrees above the southern horizon. Ruppelt wrote that they crossed this 90-degree arc in about 3 seconds, or about 30 degrees per second.
The altitude was never determined. According to Ruppelt, two teams set up far apart with angle-measuring devices and radios to triangulate the distance. On those nights, however, the lights did not appear. Meanwhile, the professors' wives sometimes saw them from home while the men waited elsewhere.
According to LIFE magazine, the professors estimated that if the lights were at 1,500 m (5,000 ft), they were moving at about 2,900 km/h. Because the lights were silent, some scientists suggested an altitude of about 15,000 m (50,000 ft), which would mean about 29,000 km/h. Angular speed gives a true speed only if the altitude is known.
A freshman's photographs
Carl Hart Jr., an 18-year-old freshman at the college, was lying by an open window at his parents' house late one night when he saw a formation of lights pass. He took his Kodak 35 camera into the backyard, set at f/3.5 and 1/10 of a second. He took five pictures as two more formations passed.
Even the Air Force records disagree on the date. The report text says the photos were taken at about 11:30 p.m. on August 31, while the photo analysis gives the same hour on August 30. LIFE also gave August 30.
The pictures show about 20 sharp points of light in a V formation. Hart took them to the local Lubbock Avalanche-Journal, which hesitated at first but then published them. In April 1952, LIFE also ran the pictures.
The Air Force investigation
At the time, the Air Force's UFO investigation was called Project Grudge; in 1952 it was renamed Project Blue Book. Edward Ruppelt, who later led the investigation, learned of the case in late September 1951 and flew to Lubbock. He interviewed the professors and Hart, and tried to recreate the photographs in Hart's backyard. Air Force personnel visited the city again from November 6 to 9.
The negatives were analyzed by the photographic laboratory at Wright Field, in a report dated November 29, 1951. Only four of the five negatives reached the Air Force. According to the analysis:
- the points of light moved relative to one another, so they were not lamps on a single object;
- no stars appear in the background, so the lights were far brighter than the stars;
- in one frame the formation is about 2% smaller than in the previous one, as if it were moving away;
- if the formation was 1.6 km away, it was about 95 m across, but the actual distance is unknown.
Using a similar camera and a moving light, Ruppelt's team managed only two badly blurred shots in four seconds. Professional photographers said an experienced photographer who panned with the motion could get sharper pictures. The lab suggested that an intense red or infrared light could look dim to the eye yet bright on film. Ruppelt summed it up: the photos were never proven to be a hoax, but neither were they proven to be genuine.
The Air Force report also mentions two unspecified discrepancies in the photos. Because of them, Hart was questioned again by the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (OSI).
The professors didn't recognize them
On April 28, 1952, the four professors wrote a letter to LIFE. They said Hart's pictures differed essentially from the 12 or more groups they had seen. Their lights were faint and soft. Most groups had no shape at all, only three formed arcs, and none formed a V. The lights were visible for about 3 seconds and moved too fast to photograph without blur. LIFE's editors replied that Air Force experts still considered Hart's pictures valid.
In 1993, Hart told researcher Kevin Randle that he didn't know what he had photographed. Asked whether he had faked the pictures, he answered simply, "No."
Plovers in the streetlights?
In Lubbock, Ruppelt noticed that several main boulevards were lit by bluish mercury-vapor lamps. The professors' observation spot was also near one of these roads. He suspected that the lights were migrating birds reflecting the lamplight.
According to Ruppelt, an old cowboy and his wife in nearby Lamesa also saw the lights, and one of them made a sound. The cowboy said they were plovers. A federal game warden said plovers usually fly in pairs or threes, not in flocks of 15 to 30, although there were more of them in the area than usual that fall.
The professors rejected the bird explanation. They pointed to the high apparent speed and the regular shape of the first two formations. Ruppelt himself admitted that people living far from the lit boulevards had also reported the lights. William Hams, a photographer at the Lubbock Avalanche-Journal, tried to photograph birds over the streetlights but could not produce anything like Hart's pictures.
Ruppelt changed his mind twice
In True magazine in 1954, Ruppelt wrote that the professors' lights could have been brought down by a shotgun in "a shower of feathers," meaning they were birds. In his 1956 book, The Report on Unidentified Flying Objects, he wrote that he had thought they were birds, "but I was wrong."
According to Ruppelt, a scientist watched the lights with instruments for months. This scientist identified them as "a very commonplace and easily explainable natural phenomenon." Ruppelt had promised him anonymity, so he did not reveal the explanation. According to the book, all the Lubbock sightings remained officially unknown.
Mirage or structure?
Harvard astronomer Donald Menzel wrote in LOOK magazine in 1952 that the Lubbock Lights were mirages: a temperature inversion projected distant city lights into the sky. He demonstrated the idea with a laboratory experiment. Critics say the experiment is only a general analogy and does not test the theory against the Lubbock measurements.
In 2001, UFO researcher Donald Burleson digitally enhanced Hart's photos. He said the underside of one of the points of light shows a regular, honeycomb-like pattern. The finding is disputed, and Burleson's size and speed estimates rest on an assumed object size.
The sober take
What is certain
- Between August and November 1951, several people in Lubbock, including four college professors, repeatedly saw formations of lights, mostly moving from north to south.
- By the professors' measurements, the lights crossed about 30 degrees per second. There was no sound.
- Hart's negatives show real light sources that also moved relative to one another. The Air Force could not show they were faked.
- According to Ruppelt's book, the sightings are listed as unknowns in the Blue Book record.
What is not proven
- The altitude, size and true speed of the lights. The triangulation never worked, so the figures of 2,900 or 29,000 km/h rest only on assumed altitudes.
- That Hart's photos show what the professors saw. The professors themselves disputed it.
- The explanation from Ruppelt's anonymous scientist. Neither the method nor the result was ever published.
Strengths and weaknesses of the explanations
- Birds in mercury-vapor light: this would explain the silence and the changing formations. It is also supported by the professors' spot being next to a lit boulevard and by a local witness who heard a plover call. Against it: the game warden said plovers don't fly in flocks that large, and lights were also seen far from the lit boulevards. For the measured angular speed, the lower the lights were, the lower the true speed.
- Mirage (Menzel): temperature inversions are real. Menzel's experiment, however, did not examine the Lubbock data.
- Hart's photos: no hoax has been proven, but they don't match the professors' description. Ruppelt's team could not take three pictures in four seconds, while professional photographers said an experienced photographer could.
Open question
Two questions remain: what the professors saw, and what ended up on Hart's film. The two are not necessarily the same thing. The notes of Ruppelt's anonymous scientist, if they exist, could settle the first. The fate of the fifth negative is also unknown.
Sources
- The Report on Unidentified Flying Objects (Edward J. Ruppelt, 1956, Project Gutenberg)
- The Lubbock lights by Edward Ruppelt, unabridged (Patrick Gross)
- The 1951 Lubbock Lights (Patrick Gross)
- The famous LIFE Magazine article, April 7, 1952 (Patrick Gross)
- Project Grudge / Blue Book iratok a lubbocki esetről (NICAP)
- What Our Air Force Found Out About UFOs (Ruppelt, True, 1954; NICAP)
- The Lubbock Lights: Introduction (Francis Ridge, NICAP)
- New Findings On The Lubbock Lights (Donald R. Burleson, IUR 2001; NICAP)
- Carl Hart and the Lubbock Lights (Kevin Randle)
- The Lubbock Lights of History Channel's 'Project Blue Book' (Curt Collins, AIPT)
- An Astronomer's Explanation: Those Flying Saucers (TIME)
- The Lubbock Lights (UAP Globe)